You have a right to a jury trial when charged with a crime under the United States Constitution law. Under the law, you also have a right to a jury trial in a civil case or lawsuit in most situations. While a trial by jury of your peers is one of your 6th Amendment rights, it is not the only type of trial available for criminal defendants. If you have been charged with a crime in Minnesota, you have the right to request a trial by jury or a bench trial. A bench trial has no jury, and your fate rests solely in the judge’s hands. Both types of trials have benefits and drawbacks, and it is often challenging to decide which option will be most beneficial for your case.
It is vital to remember that you do not have to make such a critical decision alone. If you are facing criminal charges in southern Minnesota, contact an experienced criminal defense lawyer as soon as possible. Your lawyer will use their legal expertise and their deep understanding of the law to review your case and advise you on the best course of action.
Table of Contents
Requesting a jury trial has many advantages that may help the success of your criminal case, many of which are the result of your case being heard by a group rather than a single individual. Some advantages of requesting a jury trial include:
When you request a trial by jury, the defense and prosecution each get to select the people who will serve on the jury. In addition, the defense and prosecution can have prospective jurors stricken from the jury. This could benefit your case because you and your lawyer can try to select individuals you believe will empathize with your side of the story. This is a good way for your lawyer to use the law in your favor.
Unlike an impartial judge, the panel of individuals on your jury could be swayed by emotion and personal experience. This may work in your favor. If you have been overcharged for the crime in question or are a sympathetic defendant, some jurors may be more likely to back you. They can look past the law and see the human in the situation.
When six jurors (or 12 jurors) on a grand jury must come to an agreement on the verdict, as in a criminal case, there can be room for disagreement. Every juror will have their own opinion on the case and must agree on finding you guilty or innocent. If even one jury member does not agree with the final verdict, your charges could be dropped entirely.
After all the evidence is presented to the courtroom, the defense may file a motion for acquittal. In other words, the defense may ask the judge if there is sufficient evidence for the trial to continue. If the judge finds that there is not enough evidence to convict you, the trial will end, and you will be found not guilty. If the judge does not rule in your favor, the case will continue to jury deliberations.
Jury trials are more complex than bench trials, which means more things could potentially go wrong. If the jury was tampered with or jurors participated in misconduct, you may have grounds for an appeal if you are found guilty.
The American justice system, deeply rooted in the principle of a fair trial by peers, relies on the institution of jury trials to determine the guilt or innocence of individuals accused of crimes. In Minnesota, the process of trial by jury in criminal cases follows a well-defined set of procedures to uphold the rights of both the accused and the public.
The journey begins with the arrest of an individual on suspicion of committing a crime. After arrest, formal charges are filed by the prosecution, outlining the alleged criminal acts. The accused is then informed of the charges against them, marking the commencement of the legal process.
The arraignment serves as the initial court appearance for the accused. During this stage, the charges are read, and the accused is asked to enter a plea – either guilty, not guilty, or no contest. If the plea is not guilty, the case proceeds to the next phase.
Pretrial proceedings take place before the actual trial. These include discovery, where the prosecution and defense exchange evidence, and motions, where legal arguments are presented to address issues like admissibility of evidence or dismissal of charges.
One of the pivotal moments in a criminal trial is the jury selection process. Voir dire, the process of questioning potential jurors to ensure impartiality, takes place. Attorneys from both sides, along with the judge, participate in this critical phase to select a fair and unbiased jury.
Once the jury is selected, the trial begins. The prosecution and defense present their opening statement, outlining their respective cases and providing an overview of the evidence they intend to present to the jury and the court.
The heart of the trial involves the presentation of evidence. Witnesses are called to testify, and exhibits are introduced to establish facts and support legal arguments. The prosecution bears the burden of proving to the courtroom the person accused is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
After each witness for the prosecution testifies, the defense has the opportunity for them to cross-examine and ask further questions. This process allows them to challenge the credibility of witnesses and the strength of the evidence. The prosecution may then present rebuttal evidence.
Attorneys for both sides deliver closing arguments, summarizing the evidence and arguments presented throughout the trial. They aim to persuade the jury to reach a verdict in favor of their respective positions.
Before deliberations and sending them out to the jury room, the judge provides the jury with further instructions on the relevant law. These instructions guide the jury in applying the law to the facts presented during the trial.
The jury retires to a private jury room to deliberate on the guilt or innocence of the accused. This process involves a thorough review of the evidence and the judge’s instructions, leading to the ultimate decision.
Once the jurors agree to a unanimous verdict, it is announced in open court. If the verdict is not guilty, the accused is acquitted. If guilty, a separate sentencing phase follows to determine the appropriate punishment.
A defense attorney’s role extends beyond courtroom appearances, encompassing strategic planning, legal expertise, and unwavering advocacy. They’re committed to providing the best legal services throughout the entire criminal case and trial process.
A criminal defense lawyer initiates their involvement by conducting an exhaustive analysis of the case. This involves scrutinizing evidence, witness statements, and legal precedents. This meticulous examination enables them to identify potential weaknesses in the prosecution’s case and formulate a robust defense strategy tailored to the unique circumstances of the accused to present in court. They understand the law and how to use it to help their clients face their charges and jury trials.
As the trial by jury unfolds, a criminal defense lawyer provides essential legal counsel and advice to the accused. They explain the charges, potential consequences, and the implications of various legal decisions. Armed with a deep understanding of criminal law, defense attorneys empower their clients to make informed choices at every juncture of the trial.
One of the early critical stages is the selection of the jury. A skilled defense lawyer employs strategic techniques during voir dire to identify jurors who may harbor biases or prejudices. Through thoughtful questioning, they aim to assemble a fair and impartial jury that will objectively evaluate the evidence presented.
When the case is handed over to the jury, a defense lawyer plays a role in shaping jury instructions. Clear and precise instructions aid the jury in applying the law to the facts presented. During deliberations, defense attorneys may have the opportunity to address concerns or questions raised by the jury.
Regardless of the verdict, a defense lawyer continues to represent their client in post-trial matters. If the verdict is not guilty, they work to ensure the client’s swift release. If the verdict is guilty, they may explore avenues for appeal or advocate for a favorable sentencing outcome.
A criminal defense lawyer is committed to protecting their client’s rights and best interest throughout the entire process of a trial by jury.
Deciding whether or not to request a trial by jury can significantly impact the outcome of your case. At Knutson + Casey, we understand the weight this decision carries and will use all the legal expertise at our disposal to guide you in the right direction. Our attorneys are dedicated and passionate advocates for your rights and will work with you to craft the best possible defense strategy. Call us today at (507) 344-8888 or complete our contact form to schedule a complimentary and confidential consultation with a member of our skilled legal team.